• Chocolate Turtle

  
  
• Cookie Monster

  
  
• Your favorite topping on Vanilla or Chocolate Custard.

  
  
  18.99
• Peanut Butter Collision

  
  

Place your cake order in person or over the phone (695-8189) with one of our managers – please give us 24 hours notice, as all custard cakes are made to order.

Cakes weigh approximately 5 lbs. and can be cut into 16 - 5oz servings or 25 - 3oz servings.

• Cookie Monster

  
  

  Oreo, Cookie Dough and Hard Shell Chocolate

  5.39

  4.69

  3.69
• Peanut Butter Collision

  
  

  Peanut Butter Cups, Hard Shell Chocolate and Peanut Butter Sauce

  5.39

  4.69

  3.69
• Turtle

  
  

  Hot Fudge, Hot Caramel and Roasted Pecans

  5.59

  4.89

  3.89
• Fudge Brownie

  
  

  Brownie, Hot Fudge and Whipped Cream

  5.79

  5.09

  4.09
• Caramel Cashew

  
  

  Hot Caramel Topped with Cashew Pieces

  5.39

  4.69

  3.69
• Strawberry Shortcake

  
  

  Fresh Shortcake, Strawberries, Whipped Cream and a Sprinkling of Crushed Nuts

  5.79

  5.09

  4.09
• Banana Split

  
  

  Banana, Chocolate Syrup, Strawberries, Pineapple and Crushed Nuts

  4.99
• Grasshopper Fudge

  
  

  Oreo, Cool Mint and Hot Fudge

  5.39

  4.69

  3.69
• Hot Fudge Sundae

  
  

  4.39

  3.59

  2.99
• Sundaes

  
  

  4.29

  3.49

  2.89

• Concrete

  
  A delicious blend of custard with your favorite topping additional toppings add .69¢
  4.49

  3.62
• Malt or Shake

  
  
  3.62
• Black Cow

  
  It’s a shake made with Sprecher Root Beer
  3.62
• Sprecher Root Beer Float

  
  
  2.99

Blueberry • Cherry • Pineapple • Raspberry • Strawberry • Butterfinger • Heath • M&M’s
Whopper Balls • Peanut Butter Cup • Reese’s Pieces • Snickers • Rainbow Jimmies
Cookie Dough • Oreo • Marshmallow • Hot Fudge • Chocolate Jimmies
Hot Caramel • Cool Mint • Butterscotch • Chocolate • Peanut Butter • Hard Shell Chocolate